I was therefore very interested to read the recent decision of Master James in the case of Farmer v The Chief Constable of Lancashire  EWHC B18 (Costs) and to share it with you. Here are the key points:
- Mr Farmer (“the Receiving Party”) had the benefit of a costs order against the Defendant (“the Paying Party”).
- A Bill of Costs was prepared, and detailed assessment proceedings were commenced. The original Bill of Costs totalled £174,565.79.
- There were issues over the validity of Conditional Fee Agreements, recoverability of success fees and incorrect hourly rates which led to the service of an amended bill in the sum of £116,192.50. That total was also incorrect, and the Court found that the bill should have been drawn in the region of £66,000 to £69,000.
- The Bill of Costs had been certified as accurate and true. Certain points/items were also maintained through Replies and a Witness Statement.
- Had the Bill of Costs been prepared correctly, then the matter would have been dealt with under the Provisional Assessment scheme. This would have saved substantial time and cost for each party and the Court.
- There were also costs included in the Bill of Costs which were not recoverable inter-partes.
- The Paying party applied to strike out the remainder of the Bill of Costs, pursuant to CPR 44.11.
- The Court struck out the remainder of the Bill of Costs; the Receiving Party was entitled to nothing.
- The Receiving Party was ordered to pay the costs of the detailed assessment and re-pay the payments on account received.
In Gempride the penalty reduction was 50%. In this case the penalty reduction was a full strike out of the remainder of the costs (circa. £66,000.00 – £69,000.00).
It is fundamentally important to ensure a Bill of Costs has been prepared correctly before you certify it. Mis-certification of a Bill of Costs is a serious issue.
Mistakes happen and the Court will look more favourably on innocent mistakes which are rectified quickly. In this case, the Receiving Party pursued the matter to detailed assessment and maintained retainers that were clearly not enforceable.
In my Vlog in May, I provided 5 tips to help ensure that you avoid any mis-certification issues. Please view the Vlog to help you check a Bill of Costs (or a costs budget or statement of costs for summary assessment) correctly and to stay clear of any mis-certification arguments and costs penalties. You might want to use my 5 tips to create an internal check-list.
This blog was written by Andrew McAulay. Andrew is a Partner at Clarion and the Head of the Costs and Litigation Funding Team. Andrew can be contacted on 0113 336 3334 or at firstname.lastname@example.org